As a classroom teacher, I didn't use PowerPoint a lot, not because I couldn't, but because it was such a static medium. I used the old fashioned overhead that allowed me to write, draw, and design visuals that followed the conversation we were having. However, at times, PowerPoint was very relevant and I especially wanted to teach my students how to leverage PowerPoint to their advantage, and not stumble, like so many do, into creating slides with too much text and spending too much time reading their slides to the audience.
However, as an academic, I'm frequently speaking to large audiences in spaces that typically encourage, if not require, some sort of visual presentation. Several years ago, I participated in a PechaKucha night and it was a revelation of what PPT could inspire. Since then, I've had the pleasure of experiencing a few professional speakers and researchers who use PPT to strategically illustrate points and/or reinforce the mood/tone of their speech, rather than provide the entire text of their speech.
Rebecca Schuman takes on the pointlessness of PPT in higher education with her entertaining and informative presentation PowerPointless: Digital slideshows are the scourge of higher education. It blithely highlights the horrible habits we have all gotten into when using PPT and exposes what our students really feel about our use of text-heavy, dull, and outdated presentations. As she states, mid-way through her presentation, "A presentation, believe it or not, is the opening move of a conversation - not the entire conversation."
Although I continue to create presentations for conferences, I hope that my move toward the use of graphics and strategic selection of quoted data helps build the audience engagement in what I'm presenting. A little later in her presentation, Schuman states, "If your audience can understand everything it needs to from your slides only . . . cut 50% of the slides and 90% of the text." In other-words, if the slideshow can be read like a book, what's the point of me standing in front of you speaking? You could read it on your own time!
What do you think?
A middle/high school teacher and teacher educator's reflections on teaching and learning while negotiating the path of teacher/student/academic.
Showing posts with label higher education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label higher education. Show all posts
Friday, March 07, 2014
Thursday, May 20, 2010
Teaching and Learning Symposium 2010 - Day 2
When Bad Things Happen to Good Classes – James Wells & Eileen Callahan
Case Study discussions of ethical issues in higher education.
Letters of Recommendation –
Much of these issues have to do with relationship building. Undergrads especially need to know that part of their job as a student is to get to know the professors and, although the onus may be on the student to do this, the professor needs to create a positive and open environment that invites students into this academic relationship. Student need to be interacting with faculty early in their career and not wait until the last year.However, if an average or mediocre student asks for a letter, how can a professor handle it? In writing a letter, one must be honest about the student in a respectful way as this is an issue of credibility. In addition, this opens the opportunity to have an honest conversation about the student's characteristics.
Group Work -
The most important issue to address in using group work is the pedagogical reason for it. Does group work provide a better avenue to accomplish the task compared to individual assignments? In addition, there is a difference between cooperative work and collaborative work, therefore the task set needs to match the structure. Cooperative work means that students just need to work together, whereas collaboration requires student to depend on each other's work to accomplish the task.
Once a teacher decides on group work, it is the teacher's responsibility to provide the training and tools for students to be successful in the group work. Too often teachers assume students know how to work together, yet few have had the opportunity to participate in or observe positive group work. (Almost all students have stories of horrible experiences.) Various supports could include having students create group contracts which address deadlines, responsibilities and conflict; periodic reflective writing; peer assessment; and practice within class.
Connectedness of Faculty -
How connected should professors be? 24/7? Set times? Part of the advantage of technology is that people are available at all times, yet that can create unrealistic expectations. Instructors need to be especially clear with how and when they expect to be contacted. Face-to-face office hours are typical, which can be translated to on-line chat.
Student Write to Learn: How instructors are engaging their students through online quizzing, writing, and feedback – Robert Jeanne, Lillian Tong, Amber Smith
We know that writing increases thinking, especially when the writing is exploratory and reflective, Yet in large classes, there is little opportunity for writing and instructor feedback.
Feedback Manager, done in Moodle quizzing module, allows for large scale responses from students. The instructor asks an open-ended question online, the students answer. The instructor reads the responses. The instructor creates generic “tags” - ie, Didn't follow directions. Excellent thinking. Did you think about . . . In addition, the instructor can add individual comments. All students then receive comments via email. This is very similar to computerized report cards with a list of about 50 comments. However, the instructor sets the comments for the assignment – which makes it more relevant.
Even though the responses are semi-personalized, students found it useful to know that instructors were reading and commenting on their work. Plus, with more, but smaller writing assignments, student understanding was better developed and assessed. There were multiple examples of how various instructors implemented this Feedback Manager in large classes (150+) in chemistry, biology, and ecology.
Wednesday, May 19, 2010
Teaching and Learning Symposium 2010
Learning Partnerships that Promote Learning and Self-Authorship - Marcia Baxter Magolda
What is the purpose of higher education? There are several possible responses to this: to get a good paying job, to create well-rounded individuals, and/or to train someone for a particular job/career. Yet, Magolda has a slightly different perspective – to help young adults through the process of self-authorship for their adult lives. Self-authorship is the ability to personally define a set of beliefs and identity in which to guide interaction with other people and the world. However, according to her research, some people (in all age groups) stagnate at the developmental stage of “Following External Formulas”. In other words, depending on experts or authority to define the facts, beliefs and requirements. This is the student who happily and diligently takes notes in class and can parrot back the information. It is an easy form of “learning” as it is just information consumption. When students/people get to the point of questioning experts and authority, they are at the “Crossroads” stage. As the apt metaphors implies, the person stands in the midst of several possible pathways/beliefs and must consider each. There is a recognition that no single way is the only way, yet as a student, this becomes frustrating. It is not easy learning, but rather, mentally exhausting. Through testing out ideas and sometimes making false starts and back tracking, students are able to articulate their own ideas, beliefs and opinions, yet at the same time, be open enough to truly listen to others. This, in Magolda’s terms is “Self-Authoring”. Is higher education the only way to achieve self-authorship? Certainly not, but it should be a place where this is a major goal.
To reach this goal, teacher/mentors need to build developmental bridges at the leading edge of the person’s developmental phase and, as a partner, walk along side them on the bridge. This metaphor is quite compatible with constructivist pedagogy. Rather than pulling students kicking and screaming into new understandings, guidance is provided to lead them through the content and processes needed. Meeting students where they are, knowing where they want/should go, and providing opportunities for them to achieve this is a tremendous task for teachers/mentors.
Magolda has developed these ideas through a 24 year study. Quite impressively, the group began with 101 college freshman, then 80 graduating seniors, and just recently, follow-up with 36 of the original group. Her study has been reported in various books including: Authoring Your Life, Making Their Own Way, and Knowing and Reasoning in College. The application of these ideas can be found in Creating Contexts for Learning and Self-Authorship: Constructive-Developmental Pedagogy and Learning Partnerships.
I am interested in seeing more about the “Bridges”. How do I guide students through the various phases of reasoning, and especially when there would be students of all phases within one class? In a traditional sense, this would be called differentiation of curriculum, but it is more than a focus on ability or skill, but a recognition of individual reasoning and identity formation.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
